Trader track record — documenting results and their limitations
The account balance rose from PLN 20,000 to PLN 27,000, but another PLN 5,000 was deposited during that period. A 35% increase in the balance therefore does not mean trading earned that return. A reliable track record—a documented history of results—separates deposits and withdrawals from trading performance and identifies the period, accounts and risks covered by the report. This lesson explains which documents to collect, how to organise the data and how to present their limitations clearly. An educational example also shows why a monetary result and different return calculations do not convey the same information.

Define the population before selecting the attractive result
A track record needs a declared account population. Showing the best account can describe that account accurately while leaving a misleading impression of the trader’s total result. State whether the report covers a selected account, a specified strategy or the whole set of accounts being claimed.
Our invented report covers exactly two live-account-style records, A and B, over the same observation period. Both are valued in PLN, after all account trading charges. There are no deposits, withdrawals, transfers or other adjustments during the period. The values are equity, including open marks at the stated observation times. No actual broker documents or audited trader history are presented.
Account A begins at 20,000 PLN and ends at 22,000 PLN. Account B begins at 10,000 PLN and ends at 7,000 PLN. The declared scope is their combined result. We do not infer any path within the period, authorship of decisions or future performance from these endpoints.
Reconcile money before combining percentages
| Account | Opening / closing equity in PLN | Monetary result | Account return |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 20,000 / 22,000 | +2,000 PLN | +10% |
| B | 10,000 / 7,000 | −3,000 PLN | −30% |
| Combined | 30,000 / 29,000 | −1,000 PLN | Approximately −3.3333% |
The combined result is 2,000 − 3,000 = −1,000 PLN. Combined opening capital is 30,000 PLN and ending equity 29,000 PLN. With no flows and consistent dates and currency, the combined period return is −1,000 / 30,000 ≈ −3.3333%, rounded to four decimals.
The account returns use different capital bases. The simple mean, (10% − 30%) / 2 = −10%, gives equal weight to accounts that did not start with equal capital. It is not the combined return. Account A’s opening weight is two thirds and B’s one third; applying those weights to their returns gives the same −3.3333% result.
Name what an omission changes
A presentation of A alone would show +10% and +2,000 PLN for that selected account. Those figures are arithmetically true within that smaller scope. They do not answer the declared question about both accounts. Including B changes the sign of the combined monetary result. The error lies in presenting a subset as the full population, not in needing to alter A’s genuine endpoint return.
Keep an account register with opening and closing dates, currency, environment, strategy scope, supporting records and reasons for inclusion or exclusion. Separate live, demo and simulation histories. Do not add them into one performance series merely because all can be exported as a chart. For real external flows, the simple endpoint calculation in this exercise no longer suffices; the detailed lesson explains the additional valuation and flow evidence needed.
Keep evidence and uncertainty attached to the report
A complete two-account table still cannot establish maximum drawdown from only endpoints. Nor does it prove that no undisclosed third account exists. A claim of complete coverage requires evidence for the claimed population, while risk measures need the appropriate valuation frequency and position information. Write missing evidence as a limitation rather than filling it with a reassuring estimate.
Any external review must identify what was checked: arithmetic, source matching, account ownership, scope or a defined professional standard. A platform badge and a full assurance engagement need not answer the same question. Our synthetic arithmetic has no such assurance status.
The detailed lesson below keeps the cash-flow example, verification distinctions and report template. Use this smaller case before attaching a headline percentage: which accounts are in the claim, do the money totals reconcile, and does the percentage use the capital actually represented? A transparent historical result can support a review without proving an edge or predicting a future income.
Three exercises with worked answers
The exercise data are hypothetical. Choose an answer, then check the calculation.
From a defined account population to the full evidence register
Carry account coverage and consistent capital bases into the detailed methods for cash flows, risk disclosure and verification below.
1. Purpose and scope of the presentation
Reviewing your own process requires different material from a job interview. A journal can explain decisions; a broker statement records transactions; bank confirmations help reconcile cash flows. No single document answers every question.
| Audience and purpose | Useful material | Limit of the conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| Your own review | Journal, transaction and rule-change history, value reconciliation | Consistent records do not prove a strategy has an edge. |
| A partner reviewing the process | Rules in force on the day, deviations and execution documents | A positive result does not establish compliance with the rules. |
| Recruitment for a specific role | Performance records, if required; research, code or analysis relevant to the role | The recipient sets the requirements; a retail account cannot demonstrate every kind of competence. |
| A counterparty assessing results | An agreed source-document package and, if needed, external review | Document verification does not authorise managing someone else's capital. |
The scope may be narrower than your entire history if you state it clearly: “version B from the change date; earlier version A shown separately”. If you claim to present the full history of a mandate, include closed accounts, breaks and unsuccessful attempts. Do not choose the report's start date after seeing the result.
2. Documents and account reconciliation
Keep the original transaction export, records of open positions, deposits and withdrawals, and bank statements for the cash flows. Describe the time zone and valuation convention. The journal preserves the context of decisions; its broader structure is covered in 15.9. Trading journal and metrics.
Before comparing record counts, define the unit: an order fill, a closed position or an exposure segment. Partial fills can create several export rows for one decision. Keep an identifier map and check for gaps and duplicates. Explain each discrepancy with an amount, date and document; a fixed “acceptable percentage of omissions” does not solve the problem.
Eend = Estart + deposits − withdrawals + net P/L + separate adjustments
Here E means equity: account value including open-position valuations. The account's balance may not show an unrealised loss. Net P/L includes changes in position values and trading costs. Spread and slippage reflected in execution prices are not deducted again. Include commissions, financing and account fees exactly once; use “adjustments” only for separately identified items not already included. Show tools and taxes in a separate economic layer.
Example: one deposit halfway through the period
Synthetic data—an accounting example, not historical performance. All amounts are in PLN (Polish złoty). We assume 18 notional months; after nine months, we value the account immediately before and after the deposit. There are no withdrawals or separate adjustments. Values are after account costs. No transaction history or valuations within the subperiods are provided.
| Time | Equity before the flow | Cash flow | Equity after the flow |
|---|---|---|---|
| Month 0—start | PLN 20,000 | — | PLN 20,000 |
| End of month 9 | PLN 24,000 | Deposit +PLN 5,000 | PLN 29,000 |
| End of month 18 | PLN 27,000 | PLN 0 | PLN 27,000 |
Monetary result: 27,000 − 20,000 − 5,000 = +PLN 2,000. The first subperiod produced +PLN 4,000, the second −PLN 2,000. The PLN 7,000 increase in value therefore includes both performance and the new deposit. The ratio 7,000 / 20,000 = 35% describes the change in value relative to the opening amount, not the trading return.
TWR—time-weighted return. The first return is 24,000 / 20,000 − 1 = 20%. The second is 27,000 / 29,000 − 1 = −6.8966%. The second denominator is the value after the deposit, because those funds participate in the second subperiod. Total TWR = (24,000 / 20,000) × (27,000 / 29,000) − 1 = 11.7241% over 18 months. Annualising over a notional 1.5 years: (1 + TWR)1/1.5 − 1 = 7.6708% a year. This restates past performance; it is not a forecast.
MWR—money-weighted return. With the same data, the investor contributes PLN 20,000 initially and PLN 5,000 after 0.75 years, with PLN 27,000 remaining to recover at the end. The annual rate r satisfies 20,000 × (1 + r)1.5 + 5,000 × (1 + r)0.75 = 27,000. This gives approximately 5.8551% a year. This example has one root for r > −1. With actual dates, disclose the year-length convention; here we use notional 0.75 and 1.5 years, not XIRR based on calendar dates.
TWR neutralises external cash flows when measuring return. MWR describes the investor's outcome including the timing of capital commitments. Here, the deposit before the weaker subperiod lowers MWR relative to annualised TWR. Neither measure alone determines strategy quality, and separate accounts cannot be combined by adding percentages.
Without the valuation at the cash flow, this method cannot reconstruct exact TWR. Obtain the missing data or use a named approximation, explaining its time weights and limitations. For MWR, cash flows that change sign repeatedly may produce several solutions or none; do not select a convenient rate without disclosing that problem.
Synthetic PLN model. Change in equity, cash-flow-adjusted profit and time-weighted return are different measures. Do not present a deposit as investment performance.
Only the valuations supplied in the example: 18 notional months, no withdrawals or separate adjustments, after account costs. Arrows show the order of observations, not a known daily path.
3. Recruitment, a review partner and prop programmes
First identify the model covered by the report. Employment at an institution deploying its capital, trading your own account and a commercial evaluation programme are different relationships. Requirements for history length or a reporting platform should come from the specific vacancy or contract. No common minimum number of months or trades guarantees acceptance.
For example, FTMO describes its evaluation accounts and FTMO Account as simulated, with the possibility of a real reward depending on performance and programme terms.[3] Label such a report with the programme name, stage and rules version. Separate simulation history from compensation due and actually received. A transfer confirmation proves receipt of money, not that trades were executed in the market.
A partner reviewing the process may need evidence of rule compliance and change history. A recruiter for a research role may place more weight on a reproducible project. Match the material to the recipient's question; roles are described in 16.4.
4. What to commission from an external reviewer
Instead of requesting an undefined “account audit”, specify the task: reconcile named accounts and periods to source documents, check cash flows, costs and open positions, and recalculate metrics. Agree how broker data will be obtained, exclusions, the expected report and the reviewer's responsibilities. The written report should state both the work performed and what could not be checked.
Hiring an accounting firm alone does not define the service or assurance level. Calling a reconciliation report an audit does not make it a financial-statement audit. Compare costs using quotations for the same scope; without them, there is no basis for universal price ranges or a capital threshold above which verification “must pay for itself”.
GIPS is a separate standard. Compliance concerns a firm's fulfilment of the applicable requirements, while verification covers its policies and procedures on a firm-wide basis. A separate performance examination of a specific composite or fund has a different scope. TWR alone, a broker report or platform integration is insufficient to claim GIPS compliance.[2] This article neither certifies an account nor claims compliance with that standard.
5. What Myfxbook verifies
The operator's documentation distinguishes two verification components. The description below concerns this service feature, checked on 8 September 2026, and does not set recruitment requirements.[1]
| Label | Scope stated by the operator | What it does not establish |
|---|---|---|
| Track Record | Consistency between history displayed on Myfxbook and history supplied by the broker through the platform | Completeness of all accounts, legal account ownership or persistence of performance |
| Trading Privileges | Possession of the master password: the technical ability to trade | Independent proof of legal title to the account or truthfulness of claims about all activity |
The operator requires full verification for certain sharing features. Its instructions include verifying privileges by changing the investor password in the terminal. Follow the current instructions and do not give the report recipient your master password. Lack of integration does not invalidate documents obtained another way.
Record the synchronisation date, account type and visible data limitations in the package. Do not call badges a full independent audit. Choose reporting tools by export capabilities, metric definitions and cost; a spreadsheet with controlled formulas can also reproduce the figures.
Verification must be described by the actual question, documents and period examined. Technical trading privileges do not establish legal ownership of capital or future profitability.
6. Seven risks of misleading presentation
This list is not a ranking of fraud frequency. Missing data may reflect an error or documentation limitations; it does not by itself establish the author's intent.
| Risk | What to check | How to improve the report |
|---|---|---|
| M1. Selecting the best period | Activity start date and period-selection criterion | Disclose the earlier period and why this phase is shown separately. |
| M2. Hiding closed accounts | Accounts in the declared scope, opening and closing dates | Include completed attempts. One broker's report does not automatically cover others. |
| M3. Describing a backtest as live | Data provenance and execution documents | Separate historical research, out-of-sample testing and live trading. |
| M4. Describing demo as a live account | Account type confirmed by the provider | Label the environment and its limitations. A programme payout does not turn simulation into live trading. |
| M5. Hiding rule changes in an aggregate history | Versions, implementation dates and aggregation rules | Show both the whole history and each version's period. |
| M6. Treating a deposit as loss recovery | Valuations at cash flows and transfer confirmations | Reconcile amounts; measure performance on a cash-flow-neutral index. |
| M7. Showing one favourable metric | Denominator, costs, open losses, exposure and outcome distribution | Add risk measures and a sample definition. |
M7—an arithmetic illustration. Assume the same monetary amount represents 1R in each of 100 trades. With 70 wins of +0.30R and 30 losses of −1R, and no zero outcomes, the mean is (70 × 0.30 − 30 × 1)/100 = −0.09R, and profit factor is 21/30 = 0.70. These results are already net. A 70% win rate is insufficient to assess profitability. R is the monetary risk set before a trade; without that denominator, report results in another disclosed unit. If the monetary value of 1R changes between trades, money-based profit factor need not equal profit factor calculated from R-multiples.
7. Report profile and evidence register
Copy the fields below and replace the example with your information. Specify missing data and narrow the claim accordingly. These rows describe only the synthetic example in section 2; there is no live account or completed external audit here.
| Field | Entry |
|---|---|
| Purpose | Learning to reconcile values and cash flows |
| Account and strategy population | One notional account; no strategy or history of attempts to assess |
| Data type and source | Synthetic data in section 2's table; no broker or bank statements |
| Period, instruments and frequency | 18 notional months, valuations at months 0, 9 and 18; instruments and trade count unspecified |
| Currency and cash flows | PLN; +PLN 5,000 immediately after the PLN 24,000 valuation in month 9; no withdrawals |
| Costs and adjustments | Values assumed after account costs; adjustments PLN 0. Excludes tools, taxes and an itemised cost list |
| Open positions | Values defined as equity; position composition is not supplied, so valuations cannot be checked independently |
| Result | P/L +PLN 2,000; TWR 11.7241% for the period, 7.6708% annually; MWR 5.8551% annually under the notional year-length convention |
| Risk | Drawdown of 6.8966% between available points, unrecovered at the last point. Full MDD, exposure, leverage, concentration and win rate: data unavailable |
| Versions and changes | No strategy modelled; this is a cash-flow example |
| Review scope | Arithmetic can be reproduced from the table. No external verification of an actual account |
| Limitation | The example assesses neither skill, edge nor future income |
In a real report, add risk information: historical MDD on the equity index, sampling frequency, time from peak to recovery or an “unrecovered” label, maximum exposure and leverage with their denominators defined. Report concentration and shared-factor risk: several currency pairs may represent one bet on USD. Historical MDD does not cap future losses.
Mean R, win rate and profit factor require a closed-trade list with consistent costs and a rule for zero outcomes. Without losses, the profit-factor denominator is zero; with an empty sample, the metric is undefined. Sharpe requires a return series, frequency and reference rate. Do not invent these figures from just a few account valuations.
| Claim | Required document | What it can confirm | What it cannot confirm |
|---|---|---|---|
| “TWR is X” | Valuations before and after flows, their dates and amounts, calculations | Return within the declared scope | An edge or the complete history of all accounts |
| “This is a live account” | Provider document specifying account type | The environment of the documented account | Authorship of every decision or control of all risks |
| “I show every account” | Account register and reconciled confirmations from named providers | The scope covered by those confirmations | Undisclosed relationships with other providers |
| “Results were externally reviewed” | Dated report identifying the entity, scope, method and exclusions | What the work actually performed covered | Automatic GIPS compliance, correct taxes or future results |
8. Privacy and permission to share
Separate the source archive from sharing copies. Remove account numbers, client identifiers, contact details and secrets from public material. For an authorised recipient, retain the amounts and dates needed to check calculations and use a secure channel. Anonymisation should not prevent reconciliation. If amounts cannot be shared, create an explicitly synthetic counterpart and explain the limitation.
For material from an employer or client, check publication rights and confidentiality obligations. Merely obscuring a name may not suffice. Publishing a track record does not authorise account management or personalised advice; the actual activities determine the service's nature, as the cited Polish guidance explains.[4]
9. Losses, strategy changes and missing documents
Keep the history after a loss. Separate observation, confirmed error and a hypothesised cause in the incident account. “Performance fell after the market changed” does not prove a regime change caused it. Record dates, the operational decision and its documented outcome; 16.2 develops the evidence analysis.
After a strategy change, show statistics for both phases and the full period, with an explicit combination method. After changing brokers, retain old documents and describe execution and cost differences. Transfers between your own accounts are internal in a whole-portfolio report; do not treat them as new external capital.
If statements are missing or a withdrawal is delayed, do not delete the period from a report claiming full history. Mark the unverified segment, show receivables and separate trading performance from recovered cash. A delay alone is not a trading loss; any write-down needs separate justification.
10. Steps for preparing a report
- Define the recipient, purpose, data type and population. Start with data you already have; preparing a report does not require opening a live account.
- Archive originals and describe versions. A checksum identifies a file but does not prove its contents are true.
- Reconcile transactions, cash flows and values. Disclose every unresolved difference as a gap.
- Calculate reproducible metrics. Include a limitations profile and map each claim to documents.
- Agree sharing arrangements and any external review with the recipient. Record the scope of work performed.
Your next step is to complete one profile for a chosen period. If you cannot identify the source of the closing value, open positions or one deposit, start by obtaining that document. Organise the further work schedule in 16.9.
Frequently asked questions
Is Myfxbook mandatory when presenting results?
Can I show only the past year?
Does positive TWR prove an edge?
Does a prop-programme payout confirm live trading?
What if the journal and statement disagree?
Does history restart from zero after changing brokers?
Sources and scope of use
- Myfxbook Help — Verification, updated 4 February 2025, accessed 8 September 2026. Scope: two verification types and sharing features, not labour-market requirements.
- CFA Institute — 2020 GIPS Standards for Firms, introduction “Claiming Compliance and Verification” and section 2. Scope: distinctions between compliance, firm verification and performance examination; checked 8 September 2026.
- FTMO — How It Works, accessed 8 September 2026. Scope: simulated accounts and rewards subject to programme terms; not evidence of a particular person's payouts.
- UKNF — Provision of investment advisory services by investment firms (Polish). Scope: the nature of advice and the distinction between recommendations and information. Accessed 8 September 2026.
Numerical examples use editorial assumptions. Their arithmetic has been checked; no actual track record has been audited.