Choosing a Forex broker — twelve articles on who holds your capital

Choosing a broker starts with identifying the company that will sign your agreement and its legal basis for serving clients where you live. That determines supervision, protection of client funds and the route for pursuing claims. Next come trading costs, execution, account terms and infrastructure. These twelve articles take you through each question, teaching you to read documents, check official registers and assess your own tests. They also cover account opening, warning signs and the differences between brokers and prop trading firms. Poland provides a clearly identified regulatory example. The section ends with exclusion gates and a protocol for testing your first deposit and withdrawal.

Start with the company named in the agreement; verify account conditions and the scope of protections separately.
What you will learn in this section
  • You contract with an entity, and that entity determines the rest. Two separate questions decide the position in the Polish worked example: what kind of entity — a domestic investment firm, a bank providing investment services, an investment firm from another EEA state or a third-country firm — and how it operates in Poland: under domestic authorisation, through a branch, or through notified cross-border services without a branch. A branch and cross-border services are operating forms of a foreign firm, rather than separate entity categories. Confirm both answers in the supervisor’s registers[3], not merely in the website footer.
  • The operative retail CFD regime comes from a national measure rather than an expired EU measure. ESMA’s 2018 product intervention was temporary and expired at the end of 31 July 2019[2]. For retail CFDs offered to clients in Poland, the basis is the KNF decision of 1 August 2019[1]: instrument-specific initial margin, margin close-out, negative balance protection and a prohibition on monetary benefits to retail clients, including turnover-related rebates.
  • Use one cost convention. Count the spread once per round turn and commission twice if the fee schedule charges per side. Whether a commission-based account is cheaper depends on the spread difference multiplied by pip value, compared with round-turn commission. Monthly volume does not determine the ranking unless there is a fixed charge or a tiered commission rate.
  • The final checklist applies exclusion gates before scoring. Fourteen gates, each capable of excluding the candidate on its own, followed by sixteen scoring items to compare candidates that have passed.

1. Your contracting entity and its supervisor

A brand is a commercial name. You enter into an agreement with a company, and that company has a country of registration, a supervisor and a legal form for serving clients where you live. The same brand may serve someone in Warsaw through a different entity from someone in London or Sydney, so “is this broker regulated?” is incomplete. The precise question is: which entity will enter into the agreement with me, and who supervises that entity? The answer appears on the first page of the client agreement and in the legal documents, rather than on an advertising banner.

The chain examined article by article is: brand → legal entity → operating form in the client’s country → supervisor → client classification → instrument → account → execution model → actual cost → protection of funds → infrastructure → claims route. Each step becomes meaningful once the preceding one is established. Comparing the spreads of two offers before identifying the companies behind them means comparing figures without knowing whose terms they are.

Where to check. In the Polish worked example, entities with domestic authorisation and EEA investment firms notified to operate in Poland, through a branch or without one, appear in the registers maintained by the Polish Financial Supervision Authority (KNF)[3]. Check a firm authorised in another EU state in ESMA’s register and the home authority’s register; ESMA provides links to the national authorities’ registers[5]. Check the KNF public warnings list as an additional step[4]. It provides adverse information and may not yet cover new irregularities: the test is positive confirmation in the appropriate register, not the absence of a warning.

Identify the operative measure before entering into an agreement. For retail CFDs offered to a client in Poland, it is KNF Decision No. DAS.456.2.2019 of 1 August 2019[1], rather than ESMA’s 2018 product intervention measure, which was temporary and expired at the end of 31 July 2019[2]. The Polish decision sets initial margin requirements according to the underlying instrument, requires position close-out when cash plus unrealised results fall below half the aggregate initial margin protection, provides negative balance protection, and prohibits payments and monetary benefits to retail clients in connection with the sale of CFDs[1]. It also establishes the experienced retail client status, under which a CFD provider may reduce initial margin to 1% of notional value, but only for the four instrument types in points 4(a) and 4(b): major currency pairs, other currency pairs, the specified equity indices and gold[1]. There is therefore no universal 30:1 limit, and higher leverage does not by itself establish that a firm operates outside supervision. Article 12.10 explains how to assess such an offer; article 12.9 explains who qualifies for the status and on what terms. [POLAND — AS AT: 2026-10-09]

Supervision is not a guarantee. Authorisation entails organisational, capital and disclosure requirements, together with duties towards clients. It does not guarantee solvency, uninterrupted service, the absence of conflicts of interest or recovery of every amount. Regulation, client-asset safeguards, compensation schemes and negative balance protection are four different mechanisms, with different scopes and exceptions. Article 12.7 separates them.

The client's CFD contract with the broker and the broker's separate exposure management.
Illustration of a firm acting as CFD counterparty: external hedging of its exposure does not change the client's counterparty. Conflicts may arise in either model.

2. What this section does not cover

This section teaches a decision process: it shows you how to investigate an offer and leaves the decision to you. Some subjects are covered in their dedicated sections of the course, so that the same topic is not explained in competing versions.

  • It does not recommend a broker or provide a ranking. There is no “best brokers” table, star rating or regulator league table. You follow the assessment procedure yourself, for a specific entity, instrument and account.
  • It does not provide a complete course in securities law. Rules appear where they affect the decision, with a verification date. Asset segregation, insolvency mechanics and the full regulatory framework are covered in the regulation and security section.
  • It does not teach strategies or position sizing. A suitable broker reduces costs and operational risk; it cannot make a strategy without an edge profitable. The strategies section explains where an edge comes from; the risk management section explains how much to risk per trade.
  • It does not review platforms as products. Terminals, alerts, automation and backtesting have their own place in the course: the platforms and trading tools section.
  • It does not prepare your tax return. This section establishes who must provide tax information in the Polish example, and why that duty arises. Filing the return is covered in the tax and record-keeping section; the applicable requirements depend on your tax jurisdiction.
  • It does not treat spreads, commissions, limits or authorisation status as permanent. These can change: record the reading date and refer to the primary document.
Section 12: a four-stage broker verification process STAGE 1: ENTITY 12.1. Criteria 8 levels and a gate 12.8. Jurisdictions Entity and operating form 12.9. Opening & KYC Checks and agreement ↓ Legal gate STAGE 2: EXECUTION 12.2. Models A-Book vs B-Book 12.3. Quality Slippage and requotes 12.4. Real costs Spread + commission + swap ↓ Cost test STAGE 3: SAFETY 12.5. Account types Contract and costs 12.6. Infrastructure Bridges and data centres 12.7. Client funds Safeguards and schemes ↓ Protection STAGE 4: DECISION 12.10. Red flags Warnings and pitfalls 12.11. Prop trading Simulation vs brokerage 12.12. Checklist 14-gate protocol ✓ Final decision Verify the firm and its terms BEFORE depositing money. Section 12 provides primary sources, public registers and measurement methods.
Section 12: a four-stage due diligence process leading to the final fourteen-gate checklist.

3. The section map — twelve articles

You can read the articles in any order, although each successive question assumes that the preceding one has already been resolved.

12.1. Broker selection criteria — what actually matters

An eight-level funnel with a gate in the middle. The upper four levels — the contracting entity, legality confirmed in the register, protection of funds and the instrument you are actually buying — are pass-or-fail tests. The lower four — costs, execution, functionality and convenience — generally rank candidates that have passed the gate. Only functionality is wholly a ranking criterion, because each of the other three has its own exclusion condition. The article shows when ranking becomes exclusion. A separate section explains what cannot serve as a selection criterion.

12.2. Execution models: A-Book, B-Book and hybrid

An execution model describes what the firm does with the risk it accepts when contracting with you, rather than simply “where your order goes”. In A-Book and B-Book arrangements where the firm itself enters into the contract, the counterparty remains the entity named in your agreement. Conflicts of interest exist in both models; their form and management differ. The article explains what the execution policy can confirm and notes that firms are not required to publish the numerical split between hedged and retained risk. A market-wide estimate of retail CFD hedging cannot therefore be derived from a source that does not measure that market.

12.3. Execution quality — slippage, requotes and Best Execution

This answers one question: what execution did you actually receive on your account? It covers a sixteen-field journal, an order sample, the median and three shares of slippage, fill rate, requote rate and rejection rate, while distinguishing best execution from the everyday idea of the “best price”. The article gives no absolute thresholds: every figure is assessed comparatively, under the same conditions and with samples of the same size.

Buy journal: reference price, fill and signed slippage. A table of 12 buy fills and a histogram with five adverse, three zero and four favourable observations.
Synthetic buy sample at reference Ask 1.10000: median 0, mean −0.0333 pips and sum −0.4 pips. The data demonstrate the calculation, not measured broker performance.

12.4. Real trading costs: spreads, commissions and swaps

Spread, commission, overnight financing, currency conversion and charges outside the trade, calculated in full in the account currency for one scenario. The same convention applies throughout this section: count the spread once per round turn, and commission twice if the schedule charges per side. A final sensitivity test shows which parameter actually changes your cost; for positions held overnight, it is usually not the spread.

Spread 0.4 → 4.0 pips: compare both quote sides. Two Bid/Ask pairs and a chart widening their difference from 0.4 to 4.0 pips.
Illustrative EUR/USD quotes: Ask minus Bid is 0.4 or 4.0 pips. With a 100,000 EUR contract, the spread component costs USD 4 or USD 40 respectively.

12.5. Broker account types — how to compare their parameters

An account name is a commercial label: no rule defines what “Raw” must include or how “Pro” differs from “VIP”. The comparable information is in the instrument specification and fee schedule of the particular entity. The article identifies the fields to read and calculates the break-even condition. The cheaper account is determined by the spread difference multiplied by pip value, compared with round-turn commission; volume changes the ranking only where there is a fixed charge or a tiered commission rate. Separate topics include an account called “Pro” versus formal professional client classification, and Poland’s experienced client status, which is a retail subcategory rather than a separate classification.

12.6. Execution infrastructure — servers, LPs and latency

The terminal, broker server, routing layer, aggregator and liquidity provider form a chain in which a retail client can independently measure only two intervals. The article assigns each link to one of four categories: confirmed by a document, measured in your own test, stated by an interested party, or unknown. Its central point is that “unknown” is a valid finding, rather than a gap to fill with an assumption, and that ping is not execution time.

Order route: ping and execution are different measurements. Request and confirmation flow through the client, broker server and an optional external firm.
Conceptual order route with confirmation through the broker. Illustrative ping RTT 30 ms and send-to-confirmation 100 ms measure different events.

12.7. Capital safety — jurisdictions and broker insolvency

Which compensation scheme covers you at this particular entity, and up to what amount: the UK's FSCS, Cyprus's ICF, Poland's scheme administered by KDPW, or none, because an unauthorised entity operating without a branch may have no applicable scheme. Each of the first three has a different payout formula, not merely a different limit. The article separately examines what none of them covers, where client money is physically held, how negative balance protection works, and the documented chronology of a broker insolvency, including how long full recovery took in the case examined.

12.8. Regulation and jurisdictions — supervision, tax and trade-offs

Nationality is not a legal category. Two separate questions matter: what kind of entity it is — an investment firm, a bank providing investment services, an investment firm from another EEA state or a third-country entity — and how it operates in the client’s country. The Polish worked example distinguishes domestic authorisation, a branch and notified cross-border services without a branch. A third-country entity may conduct brokerage activity in Poland only through a KNF-authorised branch. One exception works differently from its usual description: a service initiated exclusively by the client is not treated as brokerage activity requiring authorisation. Two qualifications accompany that provision: the exception does not extend to other types of service subsequently offered to the client, and the client’s initiative must not result from the entity’s advertising or promotional activity. These answers determine five matters: supervision, compensation, the claims route, governing law and the tax-information obligation. The article also corrects two common shortcuts in the Polish example: that a Polish licence alone determines tax reporting, and that a branch is covered only by its home-state scheme.

12.9. Account opening: KYC, authorisation checks and deposits

Every request made when opening an account arises from one of three sources: a legal requirement, market practice or the particular entity’s policy. Often two apply together: legislation establishes the duty and the terms set the way it is performed. The article separates these layers at every step, from the application form and appropriateness assessment to questions about the source of funds. Without that distinction, a routine check can look like harassment and data theft can look like a procedure. It also covers document-submission channels, the complaints route and its deadlines, and three comparison columns rather than two: retail client, retail client with Poland’s experienced status, and professional client.

12.10. Red flags — how to recognise a broker to avoid

The costliest mistake can work in either direction: treating something harmless as a warning and rejecting a lawful offer, or accepting as normal a practice prohibited by the relevant supervisor. The same document resolves both. For retail CFDs in Poland, a deposit bonus and a turnover-related rebate belong to the same prohibited category. A leverage figure above 30:1, by itself, says nothing conclusive about supervision: the warning is leverage inconsistent with your classification and jurisdiction, because the threshold depends on both the instrument category and client status. Six warnings can be assessed before depositing: the entity’s identity, money the broker offers you, guaranteed profits, pressure and remote desktop access, the payment route, and demands for additional money before a withdrawal followed by “fund recovery” approaches.

12.11. Prop trading firms — the alternative and the reality

A prop trading firm is not your broker, and an account called “funded” may be a demo account using fictional money, as described in the firm’s documentation examined and quoted in the article with a reading date. With a paid challenge, your fee is a definite expense incurred before any first payout. The article establishes the contracting entity and explains why purely simulated trading generally does not require investment authorisation, calculates the expected cost of reaching a first payout, and examines the drawdown rules point by point.

12.12. Broker checklist — gates, scoring and the 30-day protocol

If you do not know where to begin: start with the entity and its register status, then protection of funds and the total cost for your trading style. Assess the platform and optional features afterwards.

Thirty items using two different mechanisms: fourteen gates act as vetoes, with one failed condition excluding the candidate, while sixteen points compare candidates that pass the gates. The list has three stages because not everything can be checked before transferring money. Some checks follow the first small deposit and others require the first withdrawal request; that is the purpose of the thirty-day protocol.

4. Problem-based navigation

The table below identifies the article to start with for a particular problem.

ProblemArticle
I do not know which company will actually enter into my agreement12.1. Selection criteria
I do not understand the difference between A-Book and B-Book12.2. Execution models
Orders suffer slippage and requotes prevent entry12.3. Execution quality
The broker advertises a 0.0 spread — what will I actually pay?12.4. Real costs
I cannot decide between an account with commission and one without12.5. Account types
I trade short moves and do not know whether the broker’s infrastructure is sufficient12.6. Execution infrastructure
What happens to my money if the broker becomes insolvent?12.7. Capital safety
The entity is authorised abroad — who protects me and where can I complain?12.8. Regulation and jurisdictions
The broker requests more documents when I withdraw — is that normal?12.9. Account opening and KYC
I receive calls offering “account management” or a bonus on my deposit12.10. Red flags
A prop firm offers an 80% profit split — is that an alternative to my own account?12.11. Prop trading
I have chosen a broker — what should I check before depositing?12.12. Checklist

FAQ

Where should I start when choosing a broker?
Identify the company that will sign your agreement and its legal basis for serving clients where you live, then confirm it in the relevant supervisor’s register. Poland’s KNF registers provide the worked example[3]. A website footer alone is insufficient. Comparing spreads, platforms and margin requirements becomes meaningful after that step, once you know whose terms you are comparing. Article 12.1 sets out the order of the criteria; article 12.8 explains the consequences of the operating form.
Should I choose a broker by its spread?
An advertised spread is one of the least useful measures because it is not the full cost of the trade. Cost includes the spread in your actual trading window, commission, overnight financing, currency conversion and charges outside the trade, calculated using one convention in the account currency. Article 12.4 shows how to build that calculation. Article 12.5 explains which account is cheaper and why the per-lot difference determines the ranking rather than volume, unless a fixed charge or a tiered commission rate applies.
Is a domestic or foreign broker better?
Nationality is not a legal category. Two questions determine the answer: what kind of entity it is — an investment firm, a bank providing investment services, a firm from another EEA state or a third-country firm — and how it operates in your country. A branch and cross-border services without a branch are operating forms of a foreign firm, rather than separate entity categories. Their combination determines supervision, compensation, the claims route, governing law and who must provide tax information under the applicable national rules. Article 12.8 explains each, using Poland as the clearly identified legal example.
Where do leverage limits for clients in Poland come from?
For clients in Poland, the relevant measure is KNF Decision No. DAS.456.2.2019 of 1 August 2019[1]. ESMA’s product intervention was temporary and expired at the end of 31 July 2019[2]. The national decision does not establish one limit for every instrument: initial margin depends on the underlying instrument, and for a client with experienced retail status it allows the provider to reduce margin to 1% of notional value, but only for the four instrument types in points 4(a) and 4(b)[1]. Article 12.10 explains how to assess higher-leverage offers. [POLAND — AS AT: 2026-10-09]
Are prop trading firms an alternative to a broker?
A prop challenge firm is not your broker. It generally does not provide an investment service, so the investment-firm client relationship and its retail protections do not arise merely from buying the challenge. Poland’s compensation scheme does not cover the challenge fee because it is not money entrusted to an investment firm; for that specific mechanism the answer is “no”, rather than “unknown”. Foreign schemes must be checked separately. The qualification concerns the classification of the service itself: where a reward depends on demo-account performance, the absence of an investment service cannot be stated categorically. A “funded” account may be a demo account using fictional money, and payouts depend on the rules and the firm’s solvency. Article 12.11 explains what you buy when paying for a challenge and the actual cost of reaching a first payout.
How can I verify that a broker is supervised?
Start with the entity’s legal name from your agreement, rather than a regulator’s logo or a link supplied in an advertisement. In the Polish example, check the KNF registers[3]; for a firm authorised in another EU state, check ESMA’s register and the home authority’s register[5]. Compare the name, authorisation number, address and domain: a clone can misuse a genuine firm’s licence number. Check the KNF public warnings list additionally[4], rather than instead. Article 12.1 gives the step-by-step procedure.

Sources

Each point is developed in the linked article, where the full source list appears. The primary documents and registers below support the claims made on this introductory page; all five were checked again on 9 October 2026. Authorisation status, limits and warnings lists change over time, so confirm the current position in the primary source before deciding.

  1. Polish Financial Supervision Authority (KNF), Decision No. DAS.456.2.2019 of 1 August 2019 establishing restrictions on the marketing, distribution and sale of contracts for difference (CFDs) to retail clients, KNF Official Journal 2019, item 27 — original decision (Polish). This supports the Polish example’s initial margin requirements (point 3), margin close-out below half the aggregate initial margin protection (point 1(b)), negative balance protection (point 1(c)), monetary-benefit prohibition (point 1(d)), and the experienced retail client status with a possible 1% initial margin only for the instruments in points 4(a) and 4(b) (points 4 and 5). Checked again: 2026-10-09.
  2. European Securities and Markets Authority, ESMA ceases renewal of product intervention measures relating to contracts for differences, release of 31 July 2019 — ESMA release. Supports the expiry of ESMA’s temporary measures at the end of 31 July 2019 after most national authorities adopted permanent measures at least as stringent. Checked again: 2026-10-09.
  3. Polish Financial Supervision Authority (KNF), Investment firms and tied agents — KNF register directory. Registers used in the Polish example to establish the contracting entity: domestic investment firms and banks providing investment services, foreign investment firms notified to operate through a branch or without one, and firms whose authorisation has been withdrawn. Checked again: 2026-10-09.
  4. Polish Financial Supervision Authority (KNF), Public warnings list — KNF warnings. Includes notifications of suspected offences, including unauthorised investment activity. It provides adverse information: absence from the list does not replace positive confirmation in the appropriate register. Checked again: 2026-10-09.
  5. European Securities and Markets Authority, Is the firm regulated? — ESMA investor guidance. Links to ESMA’s register of investment firms authorised by national competent authorities and to the registers maintained by EU and EEA authorities. Checked again: 2026-10-09.

Jarosław Wasiński

Editor-in-chief, ForexMechanics.com • Macro & FX analyst

Independent analyst and practitioner with over 20 years of experience in financial markets. Actively involved in Forex since 2007, with a focus on fundamental analysis, OTC market structure, and disciplined capital risk management.

  • Creator and editor-in-chief of MyBank.pl, providing reliable financial education since 2004.
  • Author of hundreds of in-depth market commentaries, structural analyses, and educational materials for traders and investors.
  • Advocate for market transparency, promoting education grounded in hard data and institutional reports (BIS, ESMA, CFTC).

All content is educational and informational only – it does not constitute investment advice or a recommendation. Remember: leveraged trading (Forex/CFD) carries a high risk of rapid capital loss.